Tandy, on 04 November 2009 - 12:11 PM, said:
Brees is definitely NOT the best passer in the NFL. Peyton Manning is a better passer than Brees. Tom Brady - when in form - is a better passer than Brees. He's in the top 5 or 6 - but definitely not the best passer. Right now - Matt Schaub may even be giving him a run for his money.
He is an elite passer and a great leader for the Saints - but not the best passer in the NFL.
If I ranked players on passing ability - Manning and Brady would both be at the top over Brees.
Statistically, only based on completion percentage, It goes Manning, Roethlisberger, and then Brees. No doubt manning is a great QB, along with Brady, but this season, Brees is consistently putting the ball into very tight coverages, it's just my opinion, as is yours above. I would take Peyton, Brady, and Brees to run my offense and so would the rest of the league. Peyton and Brady are also averaging 4 and 7 more attempts than Brees per game respectively.
I used the word "Passer" not Quarterback. Manning, IHO, is the best Quarterback. But pure passer right now, Brees I believe has that. He can put that ball anywhere he wants, at just about anytime.
Just my opinion...